After nearly 15 years of contentious battling and three Alaska
Supreme Court cases, the Alaska Railroad has reached an
agreement with the Eklutna Village and Eklutna Inc. to return
48.2 acres, including the Eklutna Hills, back to the Dena'ina
people of Eklutna.
"It's time to settle our differences and do what's right,"
Alaska Railroad president and CEO Pat Gamble said. "The land is
of historic and cultural significance to the people of Eklutna,
so we're returning it to the rightful owners."
The land has been used by the railroad as a rock quarry since
the mid 1940s, and, according to the Alaska Native Claims
Settlement Act and the North Anchorage Land Agreement, ownership
is to revert to Eklutna Inc. once the railroad ceases to use the
quarry."We've determined that we will no longer be using the
land," Gamble said. "After we complete the removal of stockpiled
material, we're going to return the land to Eklutna as per our
agreement."
Gamble added that railroad work crews stopped working in the
quarry in 2001.
The agreement, reached Jan. 22, involved representatives from
the railroad, the Native Village of Eklutna and Eklutna Inc.
However, for the transfer of ownership to be complete, approval
from the state Legislature is required.
That could be a sticking point to the whole deal, as there is
no legislation currently being considered for the transfer.
"The railroad officials were down in Juneau trying to drum up
support and secure a sponsor for the land transfer legislation,
but they didn't have anything ready to sponsor," Chugiak Rep.
Bill Stoltze said. "I'm not going to sponsor legislation before
I can read it and have the details, and the railroad didn't have
anything prepared when they spoke to me."
Stoltze said if a draft bill were prepared by the railroad
he'd consider it, but added he wouldn't sponsor it until he had
all the details and knew each of the parties involved was
comfortable and happy with the deal."My chief concern is trust,"
Stoltze said. "I represent the area, and I trust Eklutna Inc.
and the Village of Eklutna. But when the railroad is involved,
my antennas go up, especially considering the history of
litigation between the parties."
Despite Stoltze's radar being activated, both Gamble and Jim
Arnesen, corporate land manager for Eklutna Inc., say the deal
is all aboveboard.
"Eklutna is just getting the land and the remaining resources
intact," Arnesen said. "The transfer of ownership for this land
has no connection with other dealings that we might have with
the railroad."
"We're just being good neighbors," Gamble said. "This land is
an important part of the village, and we are happy to give it
back to the rightful owner."
Eklutna Village chief administrator David Alex sent a letter
to Stoltze, spelling out the village's support for the deal.
"We support both the goals (the railroad completing removal
of stockpiled rock and the transfer of land to Eklutna Inc.),"
he wrote. "We hope that legislation can be passed that will
allow the Alaska Railroad to make the transfer."
Under the agreement and part of the land rehabilitation, the
railroad will perform is the extraction of the 145,000 tons of
stockpiled material from the quarry.
"It cost us about $1 million to produce the rock about six
years ago when the quarry was last active," said Tom Brooks, the
lead engineer for the railroad. "Without Eklutna giving us
access to stockpile, it would cost an estimated $2 million to
produce or purchase the same amount elsewhere."
The assurance by Eklutna allowing the railroad access to the
stockpile led to federal regulations limiting the use of the
rock from the quarry to be lifted and the railroad to acquire
the necessary permits for the use of the materials.
After removing the surplus rock, the railroad will remove the
spur track leading into the quarry before returning the land to
Eklutna.
(The preceding report by Darrell L. Breese was published by
The Alaska Star on Thursday, March 1, 2007.)